SP Psychological Services logo

SP Psychological Services

Home Resources Article

A first conviction for psychosocial risk: what every leader should take from it

In December 2025 history was made in Australian workplace law.

The Department of Defence was convicted and fined $188,000 for failing to manage psychosocial risks relating to the death of a worker, the first time a Commonwealth employer has ever been convicted under federal WHS law for psychosocial risk failure.

A 34-year-old RAAF technician took his own life at RAAF Base Williamtown after being subjected to four performance management work plans over six months. His supervisors failed to manage the foreseeable psychosocial risks arising from that process.

What the court actually found matters most.

Defence admitted it breached its primary duty of care by failing to provide training for supervisors involved in the performance management process.

The policies existed. The guidelines existed. The risk was known. What was missing was the human capability to translate those documents into safe leadership practice.

Comcare was explicit, simply relying on policies and procedures as controls is insufficient to eliminate or mitigate psychosocial risks.

This is the gap that exists in organisations across Australia right now. Performance management is one of the most psychologically high-risk processes in any organisation. Every senior leader needs to ask: have our supervisors been genuinely equipped, not just informed, to manage the psychological impact of these processes?

That is not an HR question. Under Australian WHS law it is a governance question. And the personal responsibility of every leader in the organisation.

This is exactly the gap I help organisations close; building the leadership capability, psychological literacy, and risk awareness that policies alone cannot provide. Because this conviction did not begin with a failure of policy. It began with a failure of leadership capability.

And that is entirely preventable.

Book a complimentary discovery call

Related articles

Leadership

18 November 2026

The hardest part of a difficult conversation is usually not the words. It is what happens in the leader’s body in the minutes before they start the meeting.

Leadership

11 November 2026

A leader’s emotional state is contagious. Before they speak a word, their tone, pace and expression tell the team whether it is safe to speak up or time to stay quiet.

Leadership

4 November 2026

Consider a situation where an employee makes a mistake. The process was unclear and the messages they received were mixed.

Not sure where to start?

Book a short, no-obligation discovery call to talk through your goals or your organisation’s needs.